Browser Wars
26 November 2008
by
Gunthy
Filed under
Software
Over at ExtremeTech they have posted a nice article about which browser is the fastest. The post is pretty lengthy (multiple pages), but it really explains well what they did and how the technology relates.
The competing browsers are Firefox 3, Safari, Google Chrome, Opera and Internet Explorer 7. Tests performed include the new V8 javascript test, browser extensions testing, the Acid 3 test, a Flash test, a Javascript test and a general speed test.
Firstly, they performed the V8-test. This is quite a new test for the rendering of javascript. When the V8 code is included in your browser, this test is blazing fast. Currently only Google Chrome & the new Firefox alpha (MineField) include this code. Since Minefield is not officially out yet, it speaks for itself that Chrome is the winner here.
Next up is the browser extension test. This is for testing XML capabilities. Here IE7 did not come out good at all, since this is not supported in it. The winner here is Firefox, but the differences between the other 2 browsers is minimal.
Third test, Acid 3. This tests the default settings of the browser, plays an animation and compares the result to a reference. To pass this test, the browser must have a final score of 100. None of the tested software passed, but the best one was Opera with a score of 85.
Fourth up is a flash test. Of course when you install flash it’s used by all browsers, but not all render the same flash animation/video at the same speed. This test is best performed by Firefox.
Next test is for javascript. The tester used the SlickSpeed test, which is normally used by developers to test for compatibility. Here, IE7 failed miserably since the test took a ridiculous amount of time to load. Safari didn’t complete it, and the rest went OK. The winner here is Google Chrome.
Last but not least is the Webspeed test. Testing some content-rich websites, the tester checked which browser was able to load them te fastest. Differences between all browsers are not that large, but again here Chrome wins.
The final score is 1st place for Google Chrome. Firefox finishes as second and Opera as third. Safari & IE7 both didn’t perform that well. This shows again that free is (at least in this case), better. Granted, you could consider all of the tested browsers ‘free’, but the differnce is that the three ‘winners’ aren’t usually shipped with an OS. Again Firefox here is a bit of an exception on this rule since it’s becoming more & more the default in a lot of Linux distributions.
All in all, I think both Chrome & Firefox are the best browsers currently available. Chrome might be the winner today, but Minefield is looking promising as well, and might just kick Chrome of that number one place soon.
